NRZ (Non-Return-to-Zero)
A binary modulation format where the optical intensity holds at one of two levels (logical 0 or 1) for the entire symbol period. The simplest and historically dominant format in optical communications.
NRZ (Non-Return-to-Zero) is the simplest optical modulation format: a binary intensity-modulation scheme where the laser output holds at one of two levels (corresponding to logical 0 or logical 1) for the entire bit period. NRZ-OOK (NRZ with On-Off Keying) has been the dominant format in optical communications from the 1980s through the 2010s and remains widely deployed.
Operating principle. A digital "0" maps to the low optical power level (ideally zero; in practice set by the extinction ratio); a digital "1" maps to the high level. Information is encoded entirely in the time-domain intensity sequence; no phase, frequency, or polarization information is used.
The format is called "Non-Return-to-Zero" because the signal does not return to zero between consecutive 1 bits, unlike RZ (Return-to-Zero) where the signal pulses high then returns to zero each bit.
Standard parameters.
| Parameter | Definition | Typical value |
|---|---|---|
| Bit period | Time per bit | 100 ps for 10 G, 40 ps for 25 G, 9.4 ps for 106.25 G (NRZ-PAM2) |
| High level | Optical power for logical 1 | to dBm typical |
| Low level | Optical power for logical 0 | minus the extinction ratio in dB |
| Extinction ratio | in dB | 6 – 15 dB typical |
| Rise/fall time | 20%-80% transition time | for typical implementations |
Eye diagram. The NRZ eye diagram is the canonical "two-level eye":
- Two horizontal rails representing the 0 and 1 levels
- Transitions crossing through a central crossing point
- "Eye opening" at the center of the bit period, where the decision threshold is set
- Wider eye opening = lower BER
NRZ eye diagrams are easy to measure and interpret; "eye height", "eye width", and "eye mask" are standard quality metrics in 10G/25G systems.
Generation.
| Method | Description |
|---|---|
| Direct modulation (DML) | Modulate laser injection current; cheap but adds chirp |
| External modulation, Mach-Zehnder (MZM) | Drive MZM with for full extinction; standard for |
| External modulation, EAM | Electro-absorption modulator with reverse bias swing; integrated into EML |
For long-haul applications, externally-modulated lasers (EMLs) or MZMs are preferred because direct modulation introduces frequency chirp that interacts with chromatic dispersion to limit reach.
Spectral characteristics. An NRZ signal at rate has main lobe width in frequency. For rectangular bits the main lobe () holds about 90% of the power, and the side lobes fall off as .
| Bit rate | First null frequency |
|---|---|
| 10 Gb/s | 10 GHz |
| 25 Gb/s | 25 GHz |
| 28 Gb/s | 28 GHz |
| 56 Gb/s | 56 GHz |
| 112 Gb/s | 112 GHz |
The high bandwidth of high-rate NRZ is the principal reason PAM4 has displaced NRZ at 50G and above. At 100 GBaud, NRZ needs at least the 50 GHz Nyquist bandwidth and in practice about 0.75 of the symbol rate, which strains available electronic components.
OSNR requirements. For NRZ-OOK with optimum decision threshold:
where is the Q-factor (signal-to-noise quality):
For BER = : , requiring electrical SNR of dB ().
In an amplified link the same Q requirement sets a minimum OSNR at the receiver, and forward error correction lowers it by accepting a higher pre-FEC BER.
Variants.
| Variant | Description | Use |
|---|---|---|
| NRZ-OOK | Standard on-off keying | Most common; "NRZ" usually means this |
| NRZ-DPSK | Differential phase-shift keying with NRZ pulse shape | Submarine, before coherent |
| NRZ-DQPSK | Differential QPSK with NRZ | Submarine |
| CSRZ (carrier-suppressed RZ) | Phase alternates between bits | Improved chromatic dispersion tolerance |
| Duobinary | 3-level field (−1, 0, +1) from filtered NRZ, detected as two intensity levels | Half bandwidth for same bit rate |
Standards using NRZ.
| Standard | Bit rate | Distance | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| OC-192 / STM-64 | 9.95 Gb/s | up to 80 km | SONET/SDH, mid-1990s onward |
| 10GBASE-SR / -LR | 10.3 Gb/s | 26 – 300 m (OM1 – OM3) / 10 km | 10 Gb Ethernet, multi-mode/single-mode |
| 100GBASE-LR4 / -ER4 | 4× 25.78 Gb/s | 10 km / 40 km | 100G Ethernet over 4 WDM lanes; ER4 adds an SOA preamplifier |
| OTU4 client optics | 4× 27.95 Gb/s | 10 – 40 km | The same four-lane design at the OTN rate of 111.8 Gb/s |
Limitations.
- Spectral efficiency capped at 1 bit/symbol: Cannot exceed 1 bit/Hz without spectral filtering
- High bandwidth at high rates: 100G NRZ requires roughly 50 – 75 GHz electronic bandwidth
- Chromatic dispersion sensitivity: a 10G NRZ signal at 1550 nm tolerates only ~ 1000 ps/nm of cumulative dispersion; at 40G, only ~ 60 ps/nm
- Mid-bit transitions invisible: no clock recovery from runs of all-1s or all-0s (mitigated by scrambling)
- Poorer noise tolerance than coherent formats, which detect the optical field and can use soft-decision FEC
Why NRZ persists. Despite the limitations:
- Receiver is simple: a photodiode + TIA + decision circuit. No DSP, no LO, no complex calibration.
- TX is simple: a directly-modulated laser or single MZM
- Cost: $5 transceivers for 10G; $25 transceivers for 25G
- Mature ecosystem: every protocol, test instrument, and IT skillset knows NRZ
- Power consumption: very low compared to coherent, which needs a DSP, a local oscillator and fast ADCs
For short-reach datacom (LAN, datacenter top-of-rack), NRZ remains competitive even as PAM4 enters at 50G+. For long-reach (>10 km at 100G+), coherent has displaced NRZ.
NRZ and PAM4 are compared within the full chain of an optical link in Bits to Light.
References: Agrawal, Fiber-Optic Communication Systems (4th ed., 2010), Ch. 8 (modulation formats and direct-detection systems); IEEE 802.3 specifications for Ethernet NRZ standards; ITU-T G.957/G.691 for SONET/SDH NRZ standards.